How to Tell If a Diamond Is Real?

August 01, 2023

Diamonds, often hailed as a girl's best friend, are not only captivating gemstones but also symbolize lasting love and treasured memories. If you're searching for a breathtaking diamond ring to commemorate a special moment, or if you're keen to verify the authenticity of your precious diamonds, it's essential to approach this dazzling realm with both caution and knowledge. A key concern is the risk of inadvertently purchasing a counterfeit diamond. To help you in this, we've prepared a guide titled "How to Tell If a Diamond Is Real."

This guide offers valuable insights on how to tell if a ring is real, ensuring that you make an informed decision. One of the most effective methods is the diamond test, a set of techniques designed to authenticate a diamond's genuineness. Additionally, our guide includes tips on how to tell a real diamond by eye, allowing you to quickly assess a diamond's authenticity at a glance. With this knowledge, you can confidently navigate the world of diamonds, ensuring your investments are both beautiful and genuine.

For those not well-versed in a diamond's intricate structure, distinguishing a natural diamond from a fake can be quite challenging with the naked eye alone.Of course, the best way to know if a diamond is real is to consult an expert jeweler or appraiser. However, you can try to set your mind at ease by following one of these at-home tests. Remember, these will give you a good clue, but none of these tests are foolproof.


Real Diamond vs. Fake Diamonds: Which Stones Fool People?

It is a common misconception that only one kind of fake diamond exists. In reality, numerous stones can deceive the untrained eye and be mistaken for genuine diamonds. Among these are natural white sapphires, white topazes, and colorless zircons, which can be easily confused with their sparkling counterparts. Furthermore, lab-created stones such as YAG (yttrium aluminum garnet), GGG (gadolinium gallium garnet), CZ (synthetic cubic zirconia), and synthetic moissanite can all mimic the allure of natural diamonds.

While some of those gemstones have value, if you're investing in a real diamond, you want to be sure you get what you pay for. Keep in mind that testing loose diamonds is more effective, as settings can be used to hide crucial indicators.

Let's explore ten tests to help you distinguish the genuine gem from the rest.


Synthetic Diamonds vs Diamond Simulants

The jewelry market is riddled with terms that often confuse buyers: synthetic diamond and diamond simulants being prime examples. However, understanding these terms is crucial if you want to be able to tell the difference and ensure you get what you're paying for.

So, are synthetic diamonds the same as diamond simulants? The short answer is no. While they might sound similar, they represent two vastly different categories. Diamond simulants, also known as diamond substitutes, resemble diamonds but are not true diamonds. Common examples include cubic zirconia (CZ), moissanite, and YAG. Some natural gemstones, such as white sapphire and clear quartz, also fall under this category due to their diamond-like appearance.

On the other hand, synthetic diamonds are genuine diamonds, just not ones formed by Mother Nature. They are also referred to as lab-grown diamond or cultivated diamonds. They possess the same chemical and physical properties as mined diamonds.

Here's a mnemonic to help you remember: "Simulated" sounds like "similar" (but not the same). "Synthetic" sounds like "authentic" (a true diamond in essence).

Unfortunately, some sellers exploit this confusion, often using the terms interchangeably to mislead potential buyers. For instance, while labeling a stone as a synthetic diamond when it's merely a simulant is misleading, the term "fake diamond" is understandably less marketable. Spotting a fake diamond becomes even more critical when purchasing, especially online.

So, how can you ascertain if a diamond is real or fake? One clear indicator is the price. While diamond simulants may still carry a considerable price tag, it's often significantly lower than that of a true synthetic diamond. However, the best practice when investing in diamonds is to ensure they are certified by reputable agencies like the American Gemological Institute or the American Gemological Society. Moreover, consider an appraisal by a graduate gemologist for an added layer of assurance.

In essence, while diamond substitutes can be captivating and look very much like a diamond, being knowledgeable and cautious will ensure you're able to tell the difference and make an informed choice.


Comparing Moissanite and Diamond

 When considering buying a diamond, a common alternative that might come up is moissanite. Price is a significant difference, with moissanite being approximately one-tenth the cost of a mined diamond of similar size and quality. This makes moissanite an attractive choice for those seeking a large-carat white gemstone on a budget. As diamond expert O’Connell shares, there's no need to compromise quality with a lesser diamond when moissanite offers superior value.

Durability is crucial when weighing your options. Diamonds, renowned for their unmatched durability, have the highest rating of 10 on the Mohs hardness scale. Moissanite follows closely, scoring between 9.25-9.5, making it the second hardest gemstone.

The brilliance, or light bouncing off the diamond, varies between the two. Moissanite possesses more brilliance and sparkle due to its double refractive nature and greater fire, producing a rainbow-like effect. In contrast, diamonds reflect whiter light, creating a unique sheen.

In terms of color, while earlier moissanites had a yellowish tint, improvements now allow for near colorless options. Diamonds are graded from D (colorless) to Z (yellowish) and require a diamond expert, like a GIA certificate, to tell if your diamond has imperfections within the diamond or determine its exact hue.

Considering these factors and understanding how they reflect light into the diamond can help potential buyers weigh more than a real dilemma of choice. It's all about personal preferences, needs, and budget.


How can you tell a diamond from a cubic zirconia?

Cubic zirconia is a popular and affordable alternative to diamonds, frequently used in engagement rings. Its similarity to diamonds is so remarkable that it can be difficult for someone without expertise to tell the difference. If you're wondering how to tell if a diamond ring is real, there are some simple methods you can try at home. While these won't be as definitive as a professional assessment from a diamond expert, who uses specialized tools, they can give you a basic idea of whether you're looking at a real vs fake diamond. Remember, a professional's opinion is always the most reliable way to determine the authenticity of a diamond.

Appearance: Cubic zirconia often presents as colorless, owing to its manufacturing process. Conversely, diamonds, graded from D (colorless) to Z (yellowish), can possess slight colorations. While cubic zirconia can be made flawless, diamonds usually contain tiny inclusions, giving each stone a unique character. Under natural light, a real diamond radiates white light, whereas cubic zirconia emits a spectrum of colored light. The variance in the light emitted arises from the differing refractive indices and dispersion levels of diamonds and cubic zirconia.

Hardness: The undeniable hardness of diamonds, scoring a perfect 10 on the Mohs scale, outmatches cubic zirconia's 8-8.5. This significant difference translates to diamonds being less susceptible to scratches. When inspecting the edges, diamonds maintain sharp facets, unlike the duller edges of cubic zirconia. A notable aspect is the direction of polishing marks. In diamonds, they vary across facets, while in cubic zirconia, they appear consistent.

Cost: The intricacies of cutting and polishing a diamond, given its superior hardness, inflate its price. A pristine 1-carat diamond can command upwards of $7000. In stark contrast, a similar-sized cubic zirconia barely touches $20. Lab-created diamonds, emerging as a popular choice, are pricier than cubic zirconia but remain more affordable than their natural counterparts. A diamond is a significant investment, often accompanied by a certificate. Moreover, diamonds, unlike cubic zirconia, hold market value and are cherished heirlooms across generations.

In Conclusion: While cubic zirconia and lab-created diamonds are frequently used as diamond substitutes, knowing how to differentiate them is crucial. The diamond you purchase will come with its unique characteristics, and understanding these nuances ensures you make an informed choice. If still in doubt, always turn to a professional. Remember, peering dot through a real diamond offers clarity unmatched by its counterparts.


How to Tell if a Diamond Is Real at Home

To determine whether a diamond is real or possibly a fake, you can perform several simple tests right at home. These methods are helpful in verifying a diamond's authenticity. Here are some easy-to-follow steps for a home-based diamond test:

How to Tell a Diamond is Real by Eye: Examine the diamond closely. Real diamonds often have minor imperfections, known as inclusions, visible under magnification. Fakes may appear flawless or have overly exaggerated flaws.

The Cold Water Test: Begin by filling a glass with water and gently dropping the diamond into the glass. A real diamond will sink to the bottom due to its high density, whereas most fakes will float or remain suspended near the surface.

How to Tell If a Diamond Is Real glass test


The Fog Test: Breathe warm air onto the surface of the diamond. A genuine diamond will disperse the heat quickly, leaving no fog or residue. In contrast, a fake diamond will retain the fog longer.

The Heat Test: Heat can be detrimental to certain gemstones, but diamonds endure without any damage. Hold the Diamond with tweezers and pass a flame near it for around 30 seconds. A real diamond will remain unaffected, while a fake may crack, shatter or get discolored.

The Black Light Test: In a dimly lit room, position the stone under a black light (UV light). Many genuine diamonds will glow under UV light with a blue fluorescence. If the stone displays a green, yellow, or gray glow, it's probably not authentic.

The Dot Test: Draw a black dot on clean white paper and place the diamond face down over the dot. You've got a fake stone if you can see the dot through the diamond. Since real diamonds refract light, you shouldn't be able to see anything through the stone.

The Newspaper Test: This is similar to the dot test. Under bright lights, place the flat side of the diamond on a newspaper. If you can see any of the letters, the stone isn't a real diamond.

how to tell if a diamond is real newspapper test


The Sparkle Test: Hold the stone in front of a light and observe how the diamond sparkles. Genuine diamonds have exceptional brilliance, with light reflecting off multiple facets. Counterfeit stones may lack this captivating sparkle and appear dull.

Check the Setting & Mount: Examine the diamond's setting and mount for any markings. This is not a foolproof test, but jewelers don't set expensive stones in cheap metal settings. For example, you're probably not looking at a real diamond if you don't see a stamp for gold (14K, 18k) or platinum (PT).

Use A Loupe or Magnifying Glass: A jeweler's loupe is like a small magnifying glass – either will work fine for this test. Inspect the diamond's surface through a magnifying tool and look for imperfections. Real diamonds often have imperfections or flaws, and while there are some flawless diamonds, those tend to sell for millions of dollars. If the stone looks too perfect, it's a fake diamond.

Use A Diamond Tester: For a more sophisticated approach, invest in a diamond tester. This tool measures electrical conductivity to identify if the stone is a real diamond or just masquerading as one. However, moissanite shows the same result as a real diamond, so you'll need to perform additional tests to be sure.

However, remember many stones look like real diamonds. To determine if your diamond is the real deal, always consult a professional. By understanding the key differences between real and fake and performing these tests, you can gain clarity on whether or not a diamond you're examining is genuin.


Sparkle With Confidence Knowing Your Diamond Is Real

To truly know if your diamond stands apart from a mere imitation, simple tests might offer a preliminary insight. However, the only foolproof way to differentiate a genuine diamond from a real one is by seeking the judgment of a professional jeweler or appraiser. At VMK Diamonds, our seasoned experts harness cutting-edge tools to sift through even the most deceptive replicas. We ensure that you're not just buying a stone but making a sound investment in a gem that will gleam through your treasured moments eternally.

With VMK Diamonds by your side, you can be confident that the diamond matches the certificate it comes with. The distinction between a genuine diamond and a fake diamond can be perfectly articulated, given the right expertise. Remember, the majority of real diamonds have distinctive features that set them apart. Be vigilant, be smart, and allow us to navigate you through the dazzling realm of diamonds, transforming the journey from daunting to delightful.

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.